(UPDATE: this looks SO much better when applied with a makeup sponge than with my fingers! Now I am liking it a bit more than before!!!). I had heard some good and some not-so-great reviews of this concealer...and since I am on the great hunt for the perfect under eye cover up, I decided to give it a go. I didn't want to waste money on a full size, so I picked up a travel size (still $10!). But the only option in travel size is "medium". It is fine though, I figured I would make it work and if I loved the formula, I would look into a better shade match. Medium is actually only a tiny bit too dark for me (I bet "light" would be too pale!). But I am glad I only got the travel size...this creases like crazy!!! It is too thick, which is good for coverage, but it looks so cakey! I wanted to love this, but it is not perfect...and I am looking for perfect. Back to the drawing board.
It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Concealer "Medium" Travel Size
Amanda Hird Arsenaultadded February 28, 2017
Bye Bye Under Eye Concealer
Another shade comparison: this time concealers. The IT Cosmetics Bye, Bye Undereye in medium is an almost exact shade match to the Younique concealer in Organza. The full sizes are pretty comparable in $$. Both are very thick, but I like the Bye, Bye Undereye a bit more than the Younique. (Also...like the divider line?!? I can't get this e.l.f. liquid liner swatch off!!!)