Amanda Hird Arsenaultadded May 4, 2017

(DECLUTTERED: I just can’t make this liner look good. Not worth the struggle!) (UPDATE: this Pencil looks a bit worse-for-wear because it did melt a bit in the car the day I was snapping its picture...this has not affected its performance though.). This Eyeliner sample came in my April 2017 Sephora Play. I am not totally impressed by this liner. It is very opaque and very creamy...but I am having issues with applying it for some reason? This is a user-error issue and not necessarily the fault of the product. Every time I draw my line on my lash line, it skips on my little eye wrinkles. And when I go back to fill in the skips, I make an even bigger mess. This is not a goof-proof liner...and I am not new to using eyeliner pencils!!! It does stay put and only smudges a little if you use it to do a wing. This would probably be a great liner for the water line (I don't line my waterline, so I can't tell you though). It is a bit on the tough side to remove at the end of the day! I REALLY want to like this liner, but I hate that I am struggling with application.

Year Made


Purchased From


Model Number



Aqua XL Eye Pencil Sample


Make Up For Ever

On These Shelves
Other Eye Products
Amanda Hird Arsenault
61 items1.2k watching
Decluttered Items
Amanda Hird Arsenault
250 items625 watching