(DECLUTTERED: I just can’t make this liner look good. Not worth the struggle!) (UPDATE: this Pencil looks a bit worse-for-wear because it did melt a bit in the car the day I was snapping its picture...this has not affected its performance though.). This Eyeliner sample came in my April 2017 Sephora Play. I am not totally impressed by this liner. It is very opaque and very creamy...but I am having issues with applying it for some reason? This is a user-error issue and not necessarily the fault of the product. Every time I draw my line on my lash line, it skips on my little eye wrinkles. And when I go back to fill in the skips, I make an even bigger mess. This is not a goof-proof liner...and I am not new to using eyeliner pencils!!! It does stay put and only smudges a little if you use it to do a wing. This would probably be a great liner for the water line (I don't line my waterline, so I can't tell you though). It is a bit on the tough side to remove at the end of the day! I REALLY want to like this liner, but I hate that I am struggling with application.
Make Up For Ever Aqua Close Eye Pencil Sample "M-10"
Amanda Hird Arsenaultadded May 4, 2017
Aqua XL Eye Pencil Sample
Make Up For Ever