Amanda Hird Arsenaultadded May 14, 2017

(DECLUTTERED: these are not creamy enough and the shades do t look right on me!). Strike two on these eyeliners. I liked how different this deep reddish brass shade was...but it is not a good shade for my eye color and skin tone!!! It is not a deep enough shade to really stand out against my eyeshadow on my upper lids. It is just a bit too red to look good on my lower lash line and it makes my eyes look more tired. However, the formula is creamy, buildable, and easy to work with. It is a giant pencil so you do get a ton of product and a just-ok sharpener in the cap. If you can find a good shade, these pencils are worth the $2 price tag!!!

Year Made


Purchased From

Rite Aid

Model Number

Copper Rose


Khol Eyeliner


Jesse's Girl