Amanda Hird Arsenaultadded August 21, 2017

This mascara sample came in my August 2017 bag. I don't love this mascara. I think a lot of the problem is the wand. It has super short bristles that I am struggling to make work. Sometimes short bristles help coat the lashes to give the lashes more volume...but this is just not happening with this sample. I blame the formula. It is thicker and not wet. I think too creamy + short bristles = hot mess for me. Sometimes I can get my lashes to fan out, but most applications end me with clumpy lashes (which I don't care for). I have noticed a little bit of smudging/flaking in my under eye. Not terrible, but it is there. I think it is because the mascara being too thick. I would hate to see this when it dries out more! I do, however, like how it makes my lower lashes look and the short bristles are ideal for that task. So I am going to keep this mascara around as a "bottom lash" mascara!

Year Made


Purchased From


Model Number

Excessive Lash


Mascara Sample


Make Up Forever