Amanda Hird Arsenaultadded December 19, 2018

(DECLUTTERED: this is just a bad palette with hardly any pigmentation.). I picked this eyeshadow trio out for my step sister to go in her coffee & tea themed Christmas gift. But I ended up with tow for some reason, so I decided to give the extra palette a go myself. The packaging is typical cheap drugstore with a sponge applicator that is pretty useless...but this is part of the new cruelty-free release from Cover Girl, so it has that going for it. But that seems to be all it has going for it. 😞. This is a pretty bad trio. There is hardly any pigmentation on any of the shadows. This has the potential to be a really nice every day palette, but it just doesn’t show up on the eyes. All three shades are shimmery and so you will need to bring in a matte crease shade. The powders don’t blend well and every time I used these the look was so muddy. I am a bit bummed that I even gave this to my step sister knowing that is so poor. Avoid this palette...I hear that the blushes in this line are good, so grab one of those instead! I know this trio will be decluttered very soon.
The shades are: a shimmery (but not at all pigmented) taupe, a shimmery light peach, and a slightly shimmery white.


Eyeshadow Trio

Model Number

105 Café Au Lait

Purchased From

Bed, Bath, & Beyond

Year Made



Cover Girl

On These Shelves
Decluttered Items
Amanda Hird Arsenault
265 items820 watching
Cover Girl
Amanda Hird Arsenault
25 items1.4k watching
Amanda Hird ArsenaultFebruary 23, 2019

@Zoebug I do like those other palettes... the ones with the weird triangle-like pans, right? The comment is just asking what you think. I loved the Pink Carnation series by her and was wondering if the writing is just as good???

ZoebugFebruary 23, 2019

@KermitsBanjo i've never read anything from this author but I am really enjoying this .......I found your comment and replied on goodreads😆

Amanda Hird ArsenaultFebruary 24, 2019

@Zoebug I recommend the Pink Carnation series!! There are quite a few books but I sucked them you won’t have any problems going through them quick!