Guess Who (MB Games - 1994)
This is like an ancient Facebook. It was really fun to play this with the neighborhood kids. I would love to try a couple of rounds of this even today.
@QuantumAxe About right. You'd know these people about as well as some Facebook followers. I wonder what the current version is like. It would just be the same picture from a slightly different angle. "Does she have a duck face pout?".